Guide
How to read a cahier des charges, the appellation rulebook
Every appellation has a rulebook. Almost nobody reads it, and it answers most of the questions.
The short answer
A cahier des charges is an appellation’s rulebook, the legal text that says what the name on the bottle requires. It sets the area, the grapes, and the numbers, from yield to release date. Read 2 side by side and the difference between 2 appellations stops being a matter of opinion.
The only document that says what the name requires
Every French appellation has one. It is approved by ministerial order, published and amended from time to time, and no other text says what the name on the bottle really requires. The INAO, the national appellation authority, publishes them, and so does the growers’ federation in Bordeaux. They run 20 to 55 pages, in plain administrative French.
The structure never changes. Learn to read one and you can read all of them.
The 8 things to find
| Look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| The geographic area | Which communes, and which parcels inside them |
| The varieties | Principal, accessory, and any admitted on trial, with their percentage caps |
| Planting density | Vines a hectare: the higher the figure, the harder each vine works |
| Yield, and the rendement butoir | The target and the absolute ceiling, in hectoliters a hectare |
| Sugar in the grapes | Grams a liter of grape juice (must): the real ripeness rule |
| Minimum natural alcohol | The alcohol that ripeness has to yield |
| Aging | The date until which the wine must be aged before it is released |
| Release | The date it may be sold to a drinker |
What Grand Cru means, in 4 lines
Put
Same land, same grapes, a different discipline. The name costs the grower about 1 bottle in 8.
The method works anywhere on the map.
Read the section on the place first
Every cahier has a section, near the end of its first chapter, on the link between the place and the wine, and it is the only part written to explain rather than to legislate. It tells you which river makes the mist, which slope faces south, when the vine arrived, and what the growers think they are doing. Then go back to the numbers, and they start to make sense.
Read that section as the appellation’s own account, not as history. Its dates and stories are the growers’ case for their name, and they carry no footnotes.
Every number has a date
Cahiers get amended. The
Where to go next
Sources: Fédération des Grands Vins de Bordeaux, the cahiers des charges · INAO,